edmondoman's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Flashdrop]

Has Potential

It starts off with lots of promise, but then leaves off with a shot of the dudes head for like 5 mins then ends, it is kind of evident that u got tired of animating by the end and just cut it off there. But if you intended it to be like that, then maybe making more clear what the message is would be helpful.

Freddih responds:

haha no, you're 100% right, I just got tired of it :P

[The Lonely Castle Crasher]

sad attempt

Can anybody tell me which part of this is funny? cause i didn't notice any humor throughout the whole thing. To improve your next animations, try using: actual animation, as apposed to just skewing the characters to talk. And try making jokes, or making the characters do something actually funny or amusing. Your attempts at blue humor failed, and the end was creepy. This whole flash was extremely contrived.

LAVAGASM responds:

I apologize that you didn't enjoy my flash. Thanks for the review!

[Mulletboy in "FROGGED"]

it was good

it was good, cool grafix, but did anyone notice that when "Mulletboy" gets hit by a car the fence beside him disapears.hhmmm... just an observation

TmsT responds:

Holy carp! That's appalling! I never actually noticed that before - Good spotting, you win teh prize! ^_<
(Meanwhile, I'm just going to go and kick myself for that one! Sheesh!)

[The Shinobi 2 PREVIEW]

It was awsome

Well i thought it was f***ing amazing,and i dont know wat some ppl are talking about in there reviews,obviously they never tried making a flash movie before, i cant even imagine all the work u put into it, so i think its stupid if anyone saisthat it sucked or it needs alot of work.
the movie kinda reminded me of xiaoxiao, but i bet the actual movie will be better.
I dont even know how you could make the actual one better, this was amazing.i think every thing was fine. but maybe u can post a aprox. date of when the real movie is coming out(and i think its crazy that u like answer every review i dont know were u find the time to do so)all i can give is 100% respect.

solidblur responds:

See here folks, this is why I make flashmovies: Reviews like this! Thank you very much for your kind words, edmondoman. I also agree that many of these people have NO idea what they are talking about but I take they advise seriously anyway, because even though they may not have made any flash, they might have seen a million of them.

I am sorry to inform you that I will not set a date for the final release, since I don't know how much sparetime I'll have in the future, not do I know how much detail I'll cram in, or how many new ideas I might get. If NG get's alot of quaitymovies before my release, I might have to increase the quality even more to get where I want, see? ;)

Anyway, the major reason for making this is to read your reviews, and this would also mean that I love responding to you ppl's reviews. So I take my time writing a response to each and everyone. If it's a serious review, you get a serious response. If it's a long one, you get a long response...you get the picture. Your review...I just love, so I'm giving you a big response ;)

Thanks again for the inspiration to work even harder!